Bears Enter September in Retreat After a Dramatic August
David Russell
September 3, 2024
Bears tried to hit the stock market in August, but were driven off by good news about the economy and earnings.
The S&P 500 began last month with a sharp selloff, initially falling more than 9 percent below its July close. But sellers quickly evaporated and the index ended the month up 1.2 percent. By some measures, it was one of the most volatile periods of all time. (See below for more.)
Technical forces seemed to explain the move: The index broke a trendline and the Japanese yen rallied. Investors also took profits in megacaps amid a lull in news.
Some pundits tried to link the selloff to a weaker economy, but then retail sales shot past expectations. Jobless claims stopped rising and the government revised second-quarter gross domestic product higher. Recession talk faded.
Perhaps even more importantly, the Federal Reserve gave dovish signals as inflation kept easing. That caused the market to expect even lower interest rates this year, according to CME’s FedWatch tool.
Optimism could additionally be building after a long period of negativity. NFIB reported the most confidence among small businesses in over two years, and the University of Michigan’s consumer sentiment index rose for the first time in five months. Consumer confidence, a separate report, inched past estimates as expectations improved.
Last month saw major changes in the market as investors shifted from large growth stocks toward sectors like consumer staples and real estate. Those companies stand to benefit from rate cuts. The rotation away from megacaps also strengthened the market’s overall breadth, which sent the advance/decline line to new highs.
Consumer staples broke out as several members rallied. Kellanova (K) was acquired by Mars and Coca-Cola (KO) rode momentum from quarterly results in July. Strong demand and increased profitability also drove Walmart (WMT) to new record highs.
Another interesting point: Berkshire Hathaway’s (BRK.B) market capitalization rose above $1 trillion. It was the first non-Nasdaq company to cross that threshold.
Energy was the worst performer. Traders are worried about Chinese demand for oil and more supply as OPEC+ countries increase production.
Charting the Market
August was an especially volatile month, with the S&P 500 traversing 532 points from low to high. It was the biggest swing since September 2022, according to TradeStation data.
CBOE’s volatility index was even more intense, whipsawing more than 51 points. That move trailed only the dramatic spike during the coronavirus lockdowns of March 2020.
Volatility later calmed and weekly fluctuations returned to the previous norms of less than 100 points.
The narrowing price action may remind some chart watchers of other moments since the rally began in November. The tight sideways consolidation patterns (marked with shaded boxes on the chart above) potentially reflect a lack of selling pressure.
Next is the price area around 5560, a weekly low in mid-July and a daily high as the index crashed. The S&P 500 tested and remained above that zone the last two weeks of August, which could suggest new support has developed near old peaks.
Some indicators of breadth may also appear favorable. For example, the Advance/Decline Line rose to a new high last week. TradeStation data also showed more than 450 members of the S&P 500 were above their 20-day moving averages last week. Similar readings, like June and November of 2023, were followed by upside in the broader market.
Finally, technology had a volatile month as money shifted to other sectors. However two catalysts may have the potential to revive interest in the sector. One is Apple’s (AAPL) product event on September 9, which is widely expected to feature a new AI-capable iPhone. Second, Nvidia (NVDA) has struggled amid delays to its Blackwell AI processors. Progress on the new super-computing chips could have a potentially big impact on tech stocks.
See the table below for more key events in September.
Big Moves in August
Top Gainers in the S&P 500 Last Month
Kellanova (K)
+39%
The snackmaker is getting acquired by Mars, 10 months after separating from cereal company WK Kellogg
Fortintet (FTNT)
+32%
The cybersecurity firm reported better-than-expected earnings and revenue.
Axon (AXON)
+22%
Earnings and revenue beat estimates at the law-enforcement supplier. Guidance was also raised.
Starbucks (SBUX)
+21%
The coffee chain hired Chipotle Mexican Grill’s (CMG) Brian Niccol as its new CEO, spurring optimism about a potential comeback.
Clorox (CLX)
+20%
The consumer-products company beat earnings estimates as cost cuts boosted margins.
Source: TradeStation Data
Top Decliners in the S&P 500 Last Month
Super Micro Computers (SMCI)
-38%
The maker of AI servers fell after profit margins weakened. It declined further after delaying its quarterly filing.
Moderna (MRNA)
-35%
The vaccine maker cut its outlook on weak demand for coronavirus inoculations.
Dollar General (DG)
-31%
The discount retailer had its biggest monthly loss ever after earnings and revenue missed estimates.
Intel (INTC)
-28%
The chipmaker hit a 14-year low after weak guidance made investors doubt its turnaround potential. The stock has lost more than half its value this year.
Walgreen Boots Alliance (WBA)
-22%
The pharmacy chain hit a 28-year low, continuing to slide on the heels of a weak quarterly report in July.
Source: TradeStation Data
Sector Watch
Consumer Staples
+6%
Real Estate
+5.7%
Health Care
+5.1%
Utilities
+4.8%
Financials
+4.6%
Industrials
+2.8%
Materials
+2.3%
S&P 500
+2.3%
Communications
+1.7%
Technology
+0.6%
Consumer Discretionary
-0.2%
Energy
-2.1%
Source: TradeStation Data
Key Economic Events in August
Below are some key economic events from last month.
Inflation goes under 3%: The Consumer Price Index (CPI) rose 2.9 percent year-over-year in July. It was the first reading below 3 percent since March 2021, and 0.1 percentage point below forecasts. Vehicle prices and air fares helped slow inflation. (8/14)
Autos drive strong retail sales: Retail sales rose 1 percent in July, more than triple economists’ forecasts. Motor-vehicles jumped by 3.6 percent. The report dispelled worries about a potential recession. (8/15)
Consumer sentiment finally improves: Consumer sentiment rose for the first time in five months, beating expectations by a narrow margin. Increased optimism about politics boosted the survey, according to the University of Michigan. (8/16)
Fed gets dovish for September: Minutes from the last Fed meeting said a “vast majority” of policy makers will probably support an interest-rate cut on 18 September 18. (8/21). Chair Jerome Powell added “the time has come for policy to adjust.” (8/23)
What Experts Are Saying
Below are some noteworthy commentaries:
Small business confidence unexpectedly rose to its highest level since February 2022, according to NFIB. There was less worry about wage pressures and more optimism about sales. They also planned to build inventories, which could support economic growth. (8/13)
Recession risks are “overstated” because “household finances remain solid,” according to UBS. The research note also cited the potential for rate cuts and estimated the S&P 500 will end the year at 5,900. (8/13)
Earnings growth is accelerating, according to FactSet. The research firm noted that profits for S&P 500 companies increased by 10.9 percent in the second quarter. It’s the fastest pace since the fourth quarter of 2021 and up from the 9.1 percent growth expected in early July. (8/16)
Risk appetite hit a one-year low in August, according to S&P Global. Worries about macroeconomic and political conditions drove the firm’s index of stock market investor sentiment to -10 percent last month, down from a multiyear high of 28 percent in May. (8/19)
The Fed will begin an “easing journey” as focus shifts from fighting inflation to maximizing employment, Paul McCulley, former chief economist at PIMCO, told CNBC. He added that Jerome Powell’s Jackson Hole speech was “absolutely marvelous.” (8/23)
Popular Futures Contracts in August
Product
Current Month
Expiration
Next Month
1-Mon%
S&P 500 E-Mini (@ES)
ESU24 (Sep)
9/20/24
ESZ24
+1.9%
Nasdaq-100 E-Mini (@NQ)
NQU24 (Sep)
9/20/24
NQZ24
+0.6%
Dow Jones E-Mini (@YM)
YMU24 (Sep)
9/20/24
YMZ24
+1.4%
Russell 2000 E-Mini (@RTY)
RTYU24 (Sep)
9/20/24
RTYZ24
-2.2%
Source: TradeStation Data
Newsworthy Events This Month
Date
Event
What to Watch For
Fri 9/5
Non-farm payrolls
Hiring and wage trends in July
Mon 9/9
Apple product event
Can AI power an iPhone upgrade cycle?
Wed 9/11
Consumer price index (CPI)
Inflation trends in August
Tue 9/17
Retail sales
The strength of consumer spending
Wed 9/18
Federal Reserve meeting
Policymakers are expected to cut interest rates
Standardized Performances for ETF mentioned above
ETF
1 Year
5 Years
10 Years
SPDR S&P 500 ETF (SPY)
+20.32
+85.19%
+185.26%
As of July 31. Source: TradeStation Data
Exchange Traded Funds (“ETFs”) are subject to management fees and other expenses. Before making investment decisions, investors should carefully read information found in the prospectus or summary prospectus, if available, including investment objectives, risks, charges, and expenses. Click here to find the prospectus.
Performance data shown reflects past performance and is no guarantee of future performance. The information provided is not meant to predict or project the performance of a specific investment or investment strategy and current performance may be lower or higher than the performance data shown. Accordingly, this information should not be relied upon when making an investment decision.
Security futures are not suitable for all investors. To obtain a copy of the security futures risk disclosure statement visit www.TradeStation.com/DisclosureFutures.
David Russell is Global Head of Market Strategy at TradeStation. Drawing on nearly two decades of experience as a financial journalist and analyst, his background includes equities, emerging markets, fixed-income and derivatives. He previously worked at Bloomberg News, CNBC and E*TRADE Financial.
Russell systematically reviews countless global financial headlines and indicators in search of broad tradable trends that present opportunities repeatedly over time. Customers can expect him to keep them apprised of sector leadership, relative strength and the big stories – especially those overlooked by other commentators. He’s also a big fan of generating leverage with options to limit capital at risk.
Downloads are available here. TradeStation’s ideas on TradingView are available here. Check out our next “State of the Market,” on Monday, 1/16. Sizing Up the S&P 500 S&P 500 falls the most since 8/5, hits low of month Prices under 8-, 21-day EMAs, 50-day MA...
Merck has struggled for most of the year, and now some traders may look for another push to the downside. The first pattern on today’s chart is the series of higher lows from mid-November through early last week. MRK has dropped below that line, which may be viewed as...
Stocks are falling as traders brace for fewer rate cuts from the Federal Reserve. The S&P 500 slid 0.6 percent between Friday, December 6, and Friday, December 13. It was the first negative week in the last four. More than three-quarters of the index's members...
Explore the Crossroads Summit
You are leaving TradeStation.com for CrossroadsSummit.com, an exciting new conference that highlights opportunity at the intersection of chaos and innovation. Click the button below to acknowledge that you understand that you are leaving TradeStation.com.
You are leaving TradeStation.com for another company’s website. Click the button below to acknowledge that you understand that you are leaving TradeStation.com.
This event is hosted on YouCanTrade. The information for this event is being provided for informational and educational purposes only.
You are leaving TradeStation Securities and going to YouCanTrade. YouCanTrade is an online media publication service which provides investment educational content, ideas and demonstrations, and does not provide investment or trading advice, research or recommendations. YouCanTrade is not a licensed financial services company or investment adviser and does not offer brokerage services of any kind.
TradeStation Securities, Inc. provides support and training channels hosted on YouCanTrade, its affiliate. Other than these support and training channels, any services offered by YouCanTrade are not sponsored, endorsed, sold or promoted by TradeStation Securities and it makes no representation regarding any YouCanTrade goods or services.
To acknowledge you are leaving TradeStation Securities to go to YouCanTrade, please click